A comparative survey in determining the imaginary characteristic roots of LTI time delayed systems
World Congress, Volume # 16 | Part# 1
Rifat Sipahi; Nejat Olgac
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
linear time invariant,time-delay systems,stability,stability tests
The aim of this study is to offer a comparison of the numerical procedures for an important problem, the determination of purely imaginary characteristic roots of LTITime Delayed Systems (LTI-TDS). This problem, in fact, has a crucial role in assessing the stability of the general class of vector LTI-TDS x = Ax + Bx(t -τ). There are many procedures discussed in the literature for this purpose. Those, which are exact, first determine the complete set of imaginary characteristic roots of the dynamics, as they constitute the only points where stability switching can take place. These approaches are, in fact, some variations of the five main methods, which may demand numerical procedures of different complexity and they may result in different precisions in finding the roots. There is, however, no comparative case study known to the authors to demonstrate the strengths and weaknesses of these methods. This document is prepared primarily for this purpose. We first present an overview of each of the five methods and then compare their numerical performances over an example case study.
 Arunsawatwong, S. (1996). Stability of retarded delay differential systems. International Journal of Control 65(2): 347-364.  Barnett, S. (1983). Polynomials and Linear Control Systems. New York, Marcel Dekker.  Brewer, J. W. (1978). Kronecker products and matrix calculus in system theory. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems CAS-25: 772-781.  Chen, J., G. Gu, et al. (1995). A new method for computing delay margins for stability of linear delay systems. Systems & Control Letters 26: 107-117.  Cooke, K. L. and P. van den Driessche (1986). On Zeros of Some Transcendental Equations. Funkcialaj Ekvacioj 29: 77-90.  Filipovic, D. and N. Olgac (2002). Delayed resonator with speed feedback-design and performance analysis. Mechatronics 12(3): 393-413.  Gohberg, I., P. Lancaster, et al. (1982). Matrix Polynomials. London, UK, Academic Press, Inc. LTD.  Gu, K. Q. and S.-I. Niculescu (2001). Further remarks on additional dynamics in various model transformations of linear delay systems. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 46(3): 497-500.  Hale, J. K. and S. M. Verduyn Lunel (1993). An Introduction to Functional Differential Equations. New York, Springer-Verlag.  Hertz, D., E. I. Jury, et al. (1984). Simplified Analytic Stability Test for Systems with Commensurate Time Delays. Proc. Inst. Elec. Eng., pt.(D), 131(1): 52-56.  Jalili, N. and N. Olgac (1999). Multiple delayed resonator vibration absorbers for multi-degreeof-freedom mechanical structures. Journal of Sound and Vibration 223(4): 567-585.  Louisell, J. (2001). A Matrix Method for Determining the Imaginary Axis Eigenvalues of a Delay System". IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 46(12): 2008-2012.  Naimark, L. and E. Zeheb (1997). All constant gain stabilizing controllers for an interval delay system with uncertain parameters. Automatica 33(9): 1669-1675.  Niculescu, S.-I. (2001). Delay effects on stability, Springer-Verlag.  Olgac, N. and R. Sipahi (2002). An exact method for the stability analysis of time delayed LTI systems. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 47(5): 793-797.  Olgac, N. and R. Sipahi (2004a). The Cluster Treatment of Characteristic Roots and the Neutral Type Time-Delayed Systems. ASME-IMECE, Paper # 59188, Anaheim, CA.  Olgac, N. and R. Sipahi (2004b). A Practical Method for Analyzing the Stability of Neutral Type LTI-Time Delayed Systems. Automatica 40: 847- 853.  Olgac, N. and R. Sipahi (To appear in March, 2005). The Cluster Treatment of Characteristic Roots and the Neutral Type Time-Delayed Systems. ASME Journal of Dynamics, System, Measurement and Control.  Qiu, L. and E. J. Davison (1991). The stability robustness determination of state space models with real unstructured perturbations. Mathematics of Control, Signals, and Systems 4: 247-267.  Rekasius, Z. V. (1980). A Stability Test for Systems with Delays. Proc. Joint Automatic Control Conf., Paper No. TP9-A.  Sipahi, R. and N. Olgac (2003a). Active Vibration Suppression with Time Delayed Feedback. ASME J. of Vibration and Acoustics 125: 384- 388.  Sipahi, R. and N. Olgac (2003b). Direct Method Implementation for the Stability Analysis of Multiple Time Delayed Systems. IEEE CCA, CD 001034, Istanbul, Turkey.  Su, J.-H. (1995). The Asymptotic Stability of Linear Autonomous Systems with Commensurate Time Delays. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 40: 1114-1117.  Thowsen, A. (1981). The Routh-Hurwitz Method for Stability Determination of Linear Differential-Difference Systems. International Journal of Control 33(5): 991-995.  Tissir, E. and A. Hmamed (1996). Further results on stability of x(t)=Ax(t)+Bx(t-tau). Automatica 32(12): 1723-1726.  Tuzcu, I. and N. Ahmadian (2002). Delay-independent stability of uncertain control systems. Journal of Vibration and Acoustics 124(2): 277-283.  Walton, K. E. and J. E. Marshall (1987). Direct Method for TDS Stability Analysis. IEE Proceedings 134: 101-107.